WHEN POWER BECOMES THE THREAT: A FORENSIC WARNING ABOUT THE NORMALIZATION OF DANGEROUS LEADERSHIP
By Dr. Kathie Mathis, Psy.D., D.D.
There is a profound psychological and forensic concern when citizens begin to fear the person who occupies the highest position of governmental authority. The issue is not whether we like a president. It is whether we are willing to objectively examine behavior, patterns, power, accountability, and the consequences of unchecked authority.
From a forensic perspective, we should not evaluate powerful individuals through charisma, political affiliation, promises, or personality alone. We examine observable behavior and patterns of conduct. Attempts to influence election administration, efforts to expand executive authority, attacks on institutional checks and balances, retaliation against perceived opponents, disregard for legal constraints, and the use of presidential clemency in controversial circumstances warrant scrutiny because institutions—not personalities—are what protect a democracy. Recent reporting and court proceedings have raised precisely these concerns, including litigation over federal intervention in mail voting and extensive presidential clemency decisions. (Reuters⁠)
THE FORENSIC QUESTION IS NOT: “DO YOU LIKE HIM?”
The forensic question is:
“What does the behavior demonstrate about the individual’s relationship with power, accountability, boundaries, and consequences?”
This is where society frequently makes a dangerous mistake.
We confuse confidence with competence, dominance with leadership, aggression with strength, loyalty with morality, and charisma with character.
In clinical and forensic work, we know that presentation can be profoundly different from underlying behavior. A person may appear charming, persuasive, generous, religious, patriotic, successful, or victimized while simultaneously engaging in behaviors that create substantial risk for others.
That is why forensic professionals look beyond the presentation.
THE NORMALIZATION EFFECT
One of the most dangerous psychological processes surrounding abusive or authoritarian behavior is normalization.
The behavior becomes progressively more extreme, but society progressively adjusts its definition of what is acceptable.
First, people say:
“He would never actually do that.”
Then:
“He didn’t really mean it.”
Then:
“Everyone does things like that.”
Then:
“At least he’s getting things done.”
Eventually:
“That’s just who he is.”
That progression should concern anyone working in victimology, domestic violence, coercive control, criminal behavior, or forensic psychology.
Because “that’s just who he is” is not an explanation of dangerous behavior. It can become an excuse for tolerating it.
POWER WITHOUT ACCOUNTABILITY
A democratic system is deliberately designed around the assumption that power must have boundaries.
The Constitution does not depend upon the goodness of one individual. It depends upon institutions capable of saying NO.
Courts must be able to say no.
Congress must be able to say no.
States must be able to say no.
Election officials must be able to say no.
Citizens must be able to say no.
And ultimately, the law must be able to say no.
When any leader begins treating accountability as persecution, oversight as disloyalty, criticism as betrayal, and legal limitations as obstacles to personal authority, the forensic concern is not merely political disagreement.
It is the relationship between power and accountability.
THE FELONY CONVICTION MATTERS
This discussion also requires intellectual honesty.
Donald Trump was convicted in New York in 2024 on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records. A federal judge’s recent ruling in August 2026 rejected his attempt to move that already-decided state case into federal court. (Reuters⁠)
In the E. Jean Carroll litigation, a civil jury found Trump liable for sexual abuse and defamation, and the Supreme Court declined to disturb that $5 million judgment in 2026. That is a civil finding, not a criminal conviction for rape, and the distinction matters precisely because forensic professionals should insist upon accuracy—even when discussing someone whose conduct they strongly oppose. (Reuters⁠)
Facts matter. Evidence matters. Court findings matter.
That is what separates forensic analysis from political rhetoric.
THE MOST DANGEROUS SENTENCE MAY BE:
“But he wouldn’t really hurt anyone.”
That sentence has been spoken by families of abusers.
It has been spoken about predators.
It has been spoken about cult leaders.
It has been spoken about violent offenders.
And throughout history, it has been spoken about leaders whose behavior was initially dismissed, minimized, rationalized, or explained away.
The forensic professional cannot afford that luxury.
We are trained to ask:
What happened?
What is documented?
What is the behavioral pattern?
Who is being harmed?
Who is being protected?
Who is being held accountable?
Who is being excused?
And what happens when the individual acquires more power?
Those questions are not partisan.
They are forensic.
DEMOCRACY CANNOT BE BUILT ON PERSONAL LOYALTY
A healthy democracy does not require citizens to trust a leader blindly.
It requires citizens to trust the system enough to question the leader.
The presidency is temporary.
The Constitution is not.
Political parties are temporary.
The rule of law is not supposed to be.
Presidents come and go.
The institutions that protect citizens must survive them.
The greatest warning sign is not simply a powerful person behaving badly.
It is a society that becomes so emotionally attached to that person that it begins defending behavior it would condemn in anyone else.
That is how normalization works.
And that is why the question before America should not be:
“Are you a Trump supporter or a Trump opponent?”
The more important question is:
“What happens to a democracy when loyalty to a leader becomes more important than loyalty to the Constitution?”
That is not merely a political question.
It is a forensic question about power, behavior, accountability, and risk.
— Dr. Kathie Mathis, Psy.D., D.D.
CEO, California Cognitive Behavioral Institute
Forensic & Clinical Specialist