THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE INDUSTRY’S BIGGEST LIE: “ZERO TOLERANCE”
We hear it everywhere:
Law enforcement. Prosecutors. CPS. Family Courts.
“We have zero tolerance for domestic violence.”
But here is the problem:
POLICY IS NOT PRACTICE.
A policy says what an agency claims it will do.
Practice is what actually happens when a terrified victim walks through the door.
And too often, the victim enters a revolving door:
POLICE REPORT → PROSECUTION → CPS → FAMILY COURT → POLICE → CPS → FAMILY COURT.
One system says, “We investigated.”
Another says, “No charges were filed.”
Another says, “CPS did not substantiate it.”
Another says, “The court has already addressed it.”
And suddenly, a failure to substantiate abuse becomes evidence that abuse didn’t occur.
Meanwhile, the victim is labeled difficult, angry, vindictive, or “high conflict.”
That is not zero tolerance.
That is institutional buck-passing.
I’m not saying every officer, prosecutor, CPS worker, or judge fails victims. Many are extraordinary professionals.
I’m saying institutions should be held accountable for what they DO—not what their policies SAY.
SO HERE IS THE CALL TO ACTION:
Stop asking agencies to show us their policies.
Show us their performance.
How many domestic-violence reports were made?
How many were properly investigated?
How many were declined—and why?
How many safety concerns were substantiated?
How many cases resulted in meaningful protection?
How many victims were retaliated against for reporting?
And when an agency fails to follow its own policy—
WHO HOLDS THAT AGENCY ACCOUNTABLE?
Because zero tolerance should not be a slogan.
It should be measurable, auditable, transparent, and enforceable.
Victims don’t need another policy.
THEY NEED THE SYSTEM TO DO WHAT IT PROMISED.
— Dr. Kathie Mathis, Psy.D., D.D.
Abuse • Trauma • Victimology • Forensic Psychology