CCBI FAMILY COURT BIAS & PSYCHOLOGICAL ENTRAPMENT ASSESSMENT

CCBI-FCBPEA

Formal Assessment Development Version

California Cognitive Behavioral Institute (CCBI)
Developed by Dr. Kathie Mathis, Psy.D.


I. ASSESSMENT PURPOSE

The CCBI Family Court Bias & Psychological Entrapment Assessment (CCBI-FCBPEA) is designed to identify and quantify indicators associated with:

  1. contextual omission;
  2. confirmation bias;
  3. manufactured credibility narratives;
  4. psychological entrapment;
  5. reversal of responsibility;
  6. victim-response misinterpretation;
  7. inappropriate psychological labeling;
  8. protective-parent misidentification;
  9. confusion between compliance and behavioral change; and
  10. professional decision-making vulnerabilities.

The assessment is intended for professional education, structured case review, research, and assessment development.

It is not intended, at this stage, to determine whether abuse occurred, establish the credibility of a litigant, diagnose a mental disorder, or independently determine custody.


II. PROPOSED CONSTRUCT

The central construct underlying the assessment is:

CONTEXTUAL FAMILY-COURT DECISION-MAKING RISK

This refers to the degree to which available information suggests that a family-court matter may be vulnerable to distorted interpretation because behavioral reactions are being evaluated without sufficient consideration of antecedents, history, power, behavioral patterns, contradictory evidence, or possible narrative manipulation.

The assessment is built around one central premise:

Behavior cannot always be accurately interpreted without examining the context that preceded it.


III. THEORETICAL MODEL

The proposed model is:

HISTORY

↓

PATTERN

↓

PROVOCATION / PRECIPITANT

↓

BEHAVIOR

↓

REACTION

↓

INTERPRETATION

↓

PROFESSIONAL RESPONSE

↓

FAMILY / CHILD CONSEQUENCE

The assessment examines whether the system has prematurely entered the model at:

“REACTION”

while insufficiently examining:

“WHAT HAPPENED BEFORE?”


IV. PROPOSED SUBSCALES

The CCBI-FCBPEA contains 10 conceptual domains.

Domain 1 — Pre-Litigation Context

Items 1–10

Domain 2 — Psychological Entrapment

Items 11–20

Domain 3 — Manufactured Credibility Narrative

Items 21–30

Domain 4 — Responsibility Reversal / DARVO Indicators

Items 31–40

Domain 5 — Confirmation Bias

Items 41–50

Domain 6 — Victim-Response Misinterpretation

Items 51–60

Domain 7 — Psychological Labeling

Items 61–70

Domain 8 — Protective Parent / Child-Safety Context

Items 71–80

Domain 9 — Compliance vs. Behavioral Change

Items 81–90

Domain 10 — Professional Decision-Making Vulnerability

Items 91–100

Each domain contains 10 items.


V. RESPONSE FORMAT

Each item is initially scored on a six-point evidentiary scale:

0 — No evidence / not present

1 — Minimal evidence

2 — Some evidence

3 — Moderate evidence

4 — Strong evidence

5 — Significant/repeated evidence

U — Unknown / insufficient information


VI. FORMAL SCORING RULE

For research purposes:

U IS NOT SCORED AS ZERO.

A “U” response indicates insufficient information.

The number and percentage of unknown responses must be reported separately.

For each subscale:

Raw Subscale Score = Sum of scored items

Maximum Possible Score = Number of scored items × 5

Standardized Subscale Score:

(Raw Score ÷ Maximum Possible Score) × 100

This produces a 0–100 percentage score while preserving the distinction between missing information and absence of evidence.


VII. TOTAL SCORE

The total score should be calculated only when sufficient items have been completed.

Recommended preliminary rule:

A total score should not be interpreted if more than 20% of the items are marked U.

If 20% or fewer are unknown:

Adjusted Total = Raw Score ÷ Maximum Possible Available Score × 500

This creates an adjusted score comparable to the 500-point scale.

However, this adjustment is a development-stage scoring procedure and must be empirically evaluated before being adopted as a final scoring rule.


VIII. INTERPRETATION

The assessment should initially be interpreted using descriptive bands rather than clinical cutoffs.

0–19%

Low concentration of identified indicators

20–39%

Some indicators identified

40–59%

Moderate concentration of indicators

60–79%

Elevated concentration of indicators

80–100%

High concentration of indicators

These are not diagnostic or legal thresholds.

During validation, empirical distributions should replace these provisional bands if evidence supports meaningful classifications.


IX. MOST IMPORTANT INTERPRETIVE RULE

THE SCORE DOES NOT ANSWER:

“Did abuse occur?”

THE SCORE DOES ANSWER:

“How many indicators requiring contextual examination have been identified?”

That distinction must remain central to the instrument.


X. ITEM-LEVEL INTERPRETATION

A high total score should never erase the importance of individual items.

A professional should identify:

TOP FIVE HIGHEST-SCORING ITEMS






Then identify:

THREE MOST IMPORTANT UNKNOWN ITEMS




The unknown items become investigative questions, not negative findings.


XI. DOMAIN PROFILE

After scoring, create a profile:

Domain Score
Pre-Litigation Context ____ / 100
Psychological Entrapment ____ / 100
Manufactured Credibility ____ / 100
Responsibility Reversal ____ / 100
Confirmation Bias ____ / 100
Victim-Response Misinterpretation ____ / 100
Psychological Labeling ____ / 100
Protective Parent / Child Safety ____ / 100
Compliance vs. Change ____ / 100
Professional Vulnerability ____ / 100

The profile should be considered more informative than the total score alone.


XII. SCORING MANUAL

A. SCORE 0

Use when there is no evidence supporting the statement or the statement clearly does not apply.

Do not use 0 simply because the information has not been investigated.


B. SCORE 1

Use when there is isolated, weak, indirect, or minimally supported evidence.


C. SCORE 2

Use when some evidence exists but the pattern remains limited or ambiguous.


D. SCORE 3

Use when moderate evidence exists or the indicator appears more than once.


E. SCORE 4

Use when strong evidence supports the indicator or the pattern is substantial.


F. SCORE 5

Use when the indicator is significant, repeated, strongly documented, or appears to operate as an important pattern in the case.


G. SCORE U

Use when the available information is inadequate.

Never convert U to 0 merely to complete the assessment.


XIII. EVIDENCE HIERARCHY

When assigning scores, participants should distinguish:

LEVEL 1 — DIRECT DOCUMENTATION

Contemporaneous records, authenticated communications, official records, photographs, recordings where legally obtained, or other independently verifiable material.

LEVEL 2 — CORROBORATED INFORMATION

Information independently supported by multiple sources.

LEVEL 3 — PROFESSIONAL OBSERVATION

Direct observations by qualified professionals.

LEVEL 4 — PARTY REPORT

A statement made by one party that has not yet been independently corroborated.

LEVEL 5 — SECONDARY CHARACTERIZATION

Descriptions such as:

“She’s crazy.”

“He’s narcissistic.”

“She’s high conflict.”

“He is the reasonable parent.”

These are characterizations—not behavioral findings.


XIV. FACT VS. INTERPRETATION WORKSHEET

For every significant allegation, complete:

FACT

What objectively occurred?


SOURCE

Who reported or documented it?


ANTECEDENT

What happened immediately before?


REACTION

What did the other person do?


INTERPRETATION

What meaning has been assigned to that behavior?


ALTERNATIVE EXPLANATION

What other explanation is reasonably possible?


CONTRADICTORY EVIDENCE

What evidence challenges the current interpretation?


UNKNOWN

What information is still missing?



XV. BIAS-INTERRUPTION RULE

Before assigning a high score to any indicator, ask:

“What evidence would cause me to score this item lower?”

Before assigning a low score, ask:

“What evidence would cause me to score this item higher?”

This creates a deliberate disconfirmation process.


XVI. PROFESSIONAL REVIEW REQUIREMENT

A completed CCBI-FCBPEA should ideally contain:

  1. the completed questionnaire;
  2. the scoring sheet;
  3. domain scores;
  4. unknown-item count;
  5. evidence notes;
  6. contradictory evidence;
  7. alternative explanations;
  8. professional observations;
  9. limitations;
  10. final contextual questions.

The assessment should not end with a numerical score.

It should end with:

“What do we still need to know?”


XVII. PSYCHOMETRIC DEVELOPMENT PLAN

PHASE 1 — CONSTRUCT DEVELOPMENT

Conduct a formal literature review addressing:

  • confirmation bias;
  • cognitive bias in legal decision-making;
  • family-court decision-making;
  • relationship abuse;
  • coercive control;
  • DARVO;
  • trauma responses;
  • victim behavior;
  • credibility assessment;
  • protective parenting;
  • custody decision-making;
  • behavioral change;
  • intervention compliance;
  • psychological assessment in family court.

Create a formal construct map showing exactly which items correspond to which constructs.


PHASE 2 — EXPERT PANEL

Recruit approximately:

10–20 subject-matter experts

Potential disciplines:

  • forensic psychology;
  • clinical psychology;
  • family law;
  • judicial education;
  • domestic/relationship abuse;
  • child welfare;
  • social work;
  • psychiatry;
  • victim advocacy;
  • psychometrics.

Each expert rates:

  1. relevance;
  2. clarity;
  3. construct fit;
  4. potential bias;
  5. potential ambiguity;
  6. appropriateness for professional use.

PHASE 3 — CONTENT VALIDITY

Calculate a Content Validity Index (CVI) for each item.

Items demonstrating inadequate relevance should be:

revised, removed, or replaced.

Experts should also identify whether an item is:

  • double-barreled;
  • leading;
  • emotionally loaded;
  • legally ambiguous;
  • diagnostically suggestive;
  • unnecessarily repetitive.

PHASE 4 — COGNITIVE INTERVIEWS

Recruit approximately:

15–30 professionals

Have participants explain:

“What did you think this question was asking?”

This identifies problems that traditional expert review can miss.

Revise items that participants interpret inconsistently.


PHASE 5 — PILOT STUDY

Recommended initial pilot:

100–200 participants

Include multiple professional groups.

Collect:

  • item responses;
  • completion time;
  • missing responses;
  • participant feedback;
  • perceived clarity;
  • perceived usefulness.

PHASE 6 — ITEM ANALYSIS

Evaluate each item for:

  • variance;
  • floor effects;
  • ceiling effects;
  • skew;
  • item-total correlation;
  • redundancy;
  • response distribution.

Items that almost everyone answers identically may provide little discrimination.


PHASE 7 — FACTOR ANALYSIS

With an adequately large sample, conduct:

Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA)

to determine whether the proposed 10-domain structure actually appears in the data.

Then conduct:

Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA)

on a different sample.

Do not use the same participants to both discover and confirm the factor structure.


PHASE 8 — RELIABILITY

Evaluate:

Internal consistency

Potential statistics:

  • McDonald’s omega;
  • Cronbach’s alpha, reported cautiously.

Test-retest reliability

Administer the assessment to the same participants after an appropriate interval.

Inter-rater reliability

Where the instrument is used for case review, determine how consistently different trained professionals score the same information.


PHASE 9 — VALIDITY

Evaluate several forms of validity.

Content validity

Does the assessment adequately represent the intended construct?

Convergent validity

Does it relate to theoretically similar constructs?

Discriminant validity

Does it remain distinct from unrelated constructs?

Criterion-related validity

Where an appropriate external criterion exists, determine whether scores correspond to it.

Incremental validity

Does the assessment provide useful information beyond ordinary professional judgment?

This last question is particularly important.


PHASE 10 — KNOWN-GROUP / CASE-BASED RESEARCH

If ethically and legally appropriate, compare assessment profiles across carefully defined case groups.

The objective is not to create a simplistic:

“victim versus perpetrator”

test.

Instead, examine whether the instrument identifies meaningful differences in contextual decision-making risk.


XVIII. SAMPLE SIZE TARGETS

A practical development pathway could be:

Expert review

10–20 experts

Cognitive interviews

15–30 professionals

Initial pilot

100–200 participants

Exploratory factor analysis

Approximately 300–500 participants, depending upon item performance and model complexity.

Confirmatory study

A separate sample of approximately 300–500 participants.

Test-retest study

Approximately 50–100 participants may provide an initial reliability estimate.

These numbers are planning targets, not rigid statistical requirements. A qualified psychometrician should conduct a formal power analysis before data collection.


XIX. IMPORTANT DEVELOPMENT DECISION

The final instrument may not remain 100 items.

Psychometric testing may demonstrate that certain items:

  • overlap;
  • fail to discriminate;
  • measure a different construct;
  • introduce bias;
  • perform poorly statistically;
  • or are redundant.

Therefore:

100 items should be considered the DEVELOPMENT POOL, not necessarily the final instrument.

A final version might contain substantially fewer items if the data support reduction.


XX. PROPOSED FINAL REPORT FORMAT

A completed professional report should contain:

1. Assessment date

2. Assessor

3. Professional role

4. Purpose of assessment

5. Information reviewed

6. Unknown information

7. Domain scores

8. Overall contextual indicator score

9. Highest-scoring indicators

10. Contradictory evidence

11. Alternative explanations

12. Limitations

13. Questions requiring further examination

14. Professional conclusion


XXI. REQUIRED CONCLUSION LANGUAGE

Until formal validation is completed, the following language should accompany reports:

The CCBI Family Court Bias & Psychological Entrapment Assessment is an assessment-development instrument intended to structure professional inquiry into contextual and decision-making indicators in family-court matters. It is not currently presented as a validated psychological test, diagnostic instrument, credibility assessment, or custody evaluation. Scores should not be interpreted independently of the underlying evidence, professional judgment, applicable law, or case-specific circumstances.


XXII. CCBI QUALITY-CONTROL PRINCIPLE

The instrument must be capable of challenging everyone’s assumptions—including the assessor’s.

The purpose is not to create a tool that proves a victim’s account.

The purpose is not to create a tool that proves a perpetrator’s account.

The purpose is to create a tool that makes professionals slow down before converting behavior into conclusions.


XXIII. THE CCBI CORE QUESTION

BEFORE WE ASK:

“What’s wrong with this person?”

WE ASK:

“What happened?”

Then:

“What happened before that?”

Then:

“What evidence supports each explanation?”

Then:

“What evidence contradicts our current conclusion?”

And finally:

“What would we need to know if we are wrong?”


CCBI-FCBPEA DEVELOPMENT STATEMENT

California Cognitive Behavioral Institute (CCBI)

The CCBI-FCBPEA is being developed as a structured professional instrument for examining contextual decision-making risks in family-court matters.

Development status: PRE-VALIDATION

Psychometric validation, normative development, and establishment of final clinical or professional interpretive thresholds remain necessary before the instrument should be represented as a validated assessment.

Dr. Kathie Mathis, Psy.D.
California Cognitive Behavioral Institute (CCBI)